This is a blog for IDS 101-16 (fall 2014) at Willamette University
Wednesday, November 5, 2014
Hercules
Hercules definitely uses the original myths as inspiration very loosely. Though I am usually a stickler for accuracy to the original story, I do not have a problem with the majority of these changes. The changes made about Hercules' parents are perfectly acceptable. The original myth about adultery and the wrath of Hera would not be the best starting point for a children's movie. As this was changed the creators of the film naturally also had to take out Hera's antagonistic actions toward Hercules, leaving the door wide open for a new villain. Hades is almost an obvious choice to fill this void, having already negative myths about him and the negative association with death. For these reasons, I find the change of making Hades the villain of the film perfectly acceptable. I am also not bothered that they changed the focus away from the labors, as this allows a more overarching and continuous storyline to be built. I appreciate that they still give references to them- with the hydra, the montage during "Zero to Hero", Phil's to-do list for Hercules, and the Cerberus scene near the end. It does bother me slightly that they changed what some of the labors were, but this I understand as well- the typical audience would be much more likely to recognize a gorgon than one of the man-eating mares of Diomedes. The only thing that really bothers me about the changes in the film is the portrayal of the titans. What is shown is not even close to what is described in original mythology and I would have enjoyed a more intelligent and complex group of adversaries.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree about the cleaned up family dynamics. I actually enjoyed this for the Hercules story. It meant that part of Hercules' choice to be mortal was for Meg, but also to live a life with his mortal parents as opposed to the Gods which was more interesting to me. I didn't think about the titans! But I agree. They could have really shown off some nice animation skills and interesting details with them.
ReplyDeleteI think what you had to say is definitely accurate! I really liked the subtle references to the labors through Phil's comments as well, and wish the writers depicted them accurately in the "Zero to Hero" montage. My knowledge about Greek mythology is very limited, but I think that for the purposes they served in the film, the titans were portrayed how they should have been. Hades is supposed to be the main villain in the film and adding more strong villains would have congested the plot rather than supported it. Plus, the film is made for children and children can only keep track of so many developed characters.
ReplyDelete